User Reviews (1 - 8 of 8)

Show these reviews first:

Highest Rated
Lowest Rated Newest
Oldest Most Helpful
Least Helpful

HOA Anthology

4 Rating: 4, Useful: 1 / 1
Date: July 02, 2008
Author: Amazon User

My husband liked the Hearts of Iron II so much and requested these. He's not been disappointed and likes it so much (Armageddon)I rarely see him when he's into a game. It did what it was supposed to do. Good Game.

Grand Strategy Done Right.

5 Rating: 5, Useful: 5 / 5
Date: May 21, 2008
Author: Amazon User

Be Encouraged! This is the BEST WW2 detailed strategy game to date. I have played this genre since the 1970's on board games to computer games.

Be Warned! This is Grand Stategy played on a clean world map, not a "point and shoot" first person. Graphics and sound are good but are not designed to target an "action game" buyer. This is a "board game" done on the computer. This is a Thinking game. It is a "Real Time" game but you can pause time, make decisions, and change direction for units and national management. Then let time go "live" again. The time increment is HOURLY starting 12am 01 January 1936 to 1953 with the "Doomsday" edition, or until 1963 with the "Armageddon" pack. And you can vary the speed of the game so that a day goes by in less than a minute.

Your units are divisional size. Battles are abstract. The computer does the losses and retreats, but you get to attach the best commanders. And YOU develop the tecnology of hardware AND types of tactical knowledge used in battle. The computer doesn't miss a step here. Smaller units CAN prevail over larger ones easily if you manage to develop the crucial details. And the Details here are excellent, as is. However tweeking the coding and cheats are available as well. In short, much customization or moding is possible and is manufactuer condoned. That's how this company's games get better. There is a strong fan base on the web, a large intelligent community. Albeit a better tutorial is needed to get your "feet wet" before diving into this deep pool of strategy.

Details needing attention? Espionage could be better handled. Diplomacy needs more "power". Swifter troop movement by rail before any ground movement needs attention. A possible encirclement or capture of whole enemy divisions is not handled, as they simply retreat very weakend, even through your lines on occassion. One assumes the region has not yet been secured. But weak units can cease to exist through attrition over time if out of supply. All Regions won surrender easily, but Nations do not, and regions gained are rarely traded perminantly for peace and a new "status quo". This again needs to be addressed in Diplomacy with negotiation to consider "national morale" versus unit or Regional morale.

On the whole, Nation Management for Money, Resources, Unit Supply, etc. are well handled and easy to adjust. The Reasearch process for Weapons and Tactics is outstanding with photos of actual people and companies of the time to direct. Leaders of the cabinet are also choosable with photos and personalities of people of the time. Combine this with photos of unit types and technology at that time and you begin to see the fantastic research done to make this product. It includes all countries of the world of 1936! Amazing. And if there is an incorrect photo or two, you can correct them behind the scenes or add your own in the database before your next session. Also amazing.

There are lot's of "what if" possibilities. In one game I played, Nazi Germany did not attack Poland, but successfully Allied with it to fight Soviet Russia! There was no British or French belligerant reaction, and the computer alowed Wendle Wilkie to be elected U.S. president on a non-interventioist platfom! In another game, Japan remained on its own and did NOT attack the U.S. but rather concentrated on China and the oil in South East Asia. No Pearl Harbor! Whatever small complaints, this game is VERY playable, and the product is Five-Star.

no control over battles?

1 Rating: 1, Useful: 0 / 5
Date: April 29, 2008
Author: Amazon User

I am very much into grand strategy games. So far though this one has not hooked me. Everything seems ok... but then when there is a battle you have no tactical control. the battle just happens.. then I'm left with an empty feeling. I do like strategic aspects of games like this, but with so many games like the Total War series I guess I just expect to have tactical control over the battles. So that a good strategy can overcome a superior enemy force at times. If I'm not mistaken this series does not even show a graphical representation of the battle. Even if it did I'd still be dissapointed about having no control.

if I run out of other games to play maybe I'll try this again. If my opinion changes I'll do another review. But for now this series and Gary Grigby's World at War are in the do not play stack.

Good expansion, could have been better

4 Rating: 4, Useful: 1 / 1
Date: April 05, 2008
Author: Amazon User

Being a long-time addict of Hearts of Iron II and Hearts of Iron II Doomsday (an extension of Hearts of Iron II through 1953), I was excited to see the Hearts of Iron II Armageddon expansion through to 1964. In that respect, it was the Hearts of Iron that all die-hard fanatics have come to know and love. My only disappointment was that the technology tree was not expanded further, with more options available to research. Other than that, it was exactly what I was looking for.

Great game

5 Rating: 5, Useful: 7 / 7
Date: January 14, 2008
Author: Amazon User

This is a great game if you don't need all the latest graphical and sound advancement. There are no battle scenes, no explosions, no sound of gunfire...This is more or less an interactive board game. But there is A LOT of depth here that you could never do with a board game.

Managing your economy, scientific advancements, leadership, and everything in-between will make the difference between world domination and historical obscurity. This game mostly plays close to historical events, but you can certainly create new paths and "what-if's."

For instance, what would have happened if Germany had beaten the USSR in 1941. Or what if the US and USSR had gone to war following WWII. But also, don't expect to have Tiger tanks rolling through Poland in 1939 or jets in the Battle of Britian...at least not without cheating.

The Anthology is great in that it has all three HoI games in one. But you could have just as much fun buying just HoI: Doomsday or HOI: Armageddon. I personally play Doomsday the most and would have been better JUST getting that game and saving a few bucks.

But the Anthology DOES come with a big `ol map and a cool little metal.

OVERALL a fun and addictive game

Are you a WWII buff? If yes, click "buy".

5 Rating: 5, Useful: 6 / 7
Date: January 09, 2008
Author: Amazon User

While this is not a game for those who want fast-paced action or fancy graphics, it also may be the best political and strategic simulator of all-time. Hearts of Iron is surprisingly addictive, allowing you to replay the game many times over. However, there is a very steep learning-curve and many casual players will feel overwhelmed. On the other hand, you don't have to be a "hard-core" gamer to enjoy this game; you can save at any time as well as pause the game to issue orders (or consult the manual). Put simply, Hearts of Iron II is the Grand-Daddy of all WWII games. Take the time to master it and you'll never get tired of this game.

Awesome Overall Complete WW2 Game

5 Rating: 5, Useful: 17 / 17
Date: December 14, 2007
Author: Amazon User

This game is only for the advanced player who wants to control all aspects of a country. The newer version helps automate some things, but is an intense game that can take a long time to play. What is neat is the ability to play any country. I bought the first and then the second. Then bought Crusader Kings and another copy of HOI came with that, but Crusader Kings wasn't any good, and is more meant for kids and had no instructions (sorry to stay off subject, but just and FYI on that).
I wish their latest upgrade for HOI had a disk available rather than only a download. I really like HOI but most people may think it is too complicated or involved w\ details. However, it is the most realistic divisional level game of WW2 there is. I've played war games for over 30 years.This is the best yet. It is real time, so hard to see it being able to play online with others as it takes too long and most people would not be able to schedule the time outs and saves.

Great Anthology

5 Rating: 5, Useful: 21 / 21
Date: October 31, 2007
Author: Amazon User

This is a great collection for people that like this kind of strategy game. You get one DVD with the lastest version of: Hearts of Iron, Hearts of Iron 2, Hearts of Iron 2:Doomsday (expansion pack) and Armageddon (booster Pack), plus a map and a medal. All for a great price. It have only played Hearts of Iron 1 or 2 and like the game, you should definetly buy this, because its hard to get all those game separately and you save a lot. The expansio pack "Doomsday" gets you until 1953, and the booster pack "Armageddon" until 1963.
It's the most complex and rewarding World War 2 strategy game to date, and it has a deeply engaging strategy with unprecedented historical fidelity.

Review Page: 1 

Actions