| Unlockable: | How to Unlock: |
| Hardcore champinship | Buy for $20,000 in WWE Shop |
| JBL | Buy for $110,000 in WWE Shop |
| Millon Doller champinship | Buy for $20,000 in WWE Shop |
| Shane Mcmahon | Buy for $110,000 in WWE Shop |
| Shawn Michaels D-X attire | Buy for $60,000 in WWE Shop |
| Triple H D-X attire | Buy for $60,000 in WWE Shop |
| Vince Mcmahon | Buy for $110,000 in WWE Shop |
| Vince Mcmahon Bald attire (First you must unlock Vince Mcmahon) | Buy for $60,000 in WWE Shop |
| WWF Attitude Era champinship | Buy for $20,000 in WWE Shop |
| Unlockable: | How to Unlock: |
| "Ravishing" Rick Rude | Buy in WWE Shop for $210,000. |
| "Rowdy" Roddy Piper | Buy in WWE Shop for $210,000. |
| "Stone Cold" Steve Austin | Go into the Hall of Fame and select Stone Cold. After defeating him in a Submission Match using Bret Hart, you can buy him in the WWE Shop. $210,000 |
| Bret Hart | Defeat Bret Hart in the Hall of Fame direct challenge mode. Afterwards, buy him in the WWE Shop. $210,000 |
| Hardcore Championship | Become a Hall of Famer ($20,000). |
| HBK DX Entrance | Buy the DX outfits ($30,000). |
| HBK DX Outfit | Already available for purchase ($60,000). |
| HHH DX Entrance | Buy the DX outfits ($30,000). |
| HHH DX Outfit | Already available for purchase ($60,000). |
| JBL | Already available for purchase ($110,000). |
| Mick Foley | Defeat Mick Foley in the Hall of Fame direct challenge mode. Afterwards, buy him in the WWE Shop. $210,000 |
| Million Dollar Championship | Become a Hall of Famer ($20,000). |
| Move Set 1 | Already available for purchase ($15,000). |
| Move Set 2 | Already available for purchase ($15,000). |
| Move Set 3 | Already available for purchase ($15,000). |
| Preset Move Set | Buy all move sets ($15,000). |
| Rick Rude | Already available for purchase ($210,000). |
| Roddy Piper | Already available for purchase ($210,000). |
| Sabu | Buy in the WWE Shop for $210,000 |
| Shane McMahon | Already available for purchase ($60,000). |
| Terry Funk | Defeat Tommy Dreamer, Sabu and Sandman in an ECW Extreme Rules 4-way match using any superstar on "Legend" Difficulty. $210,000. |
| The Rock | Defeat The Rock as Stone Cold in "Legend" Difficulty. $210,000 |
| Vince McMahon | Complete 24/7 GM mode and become GM Of The Year ($110,000). |
| Vince McMahon (Bald) | Buy the original Vince McMahon ($60,000). |
| WCW Classic | Championship: Become be a Hall of Famer ($20,000). |
| WWF Attitude Era | Championship: Become be a Hall of Famer ($20,000). |
| Unlockable: | How to Unlock: |
| December to Dismember Arena | Get 8 points in Hall of Fame Mode |
| ECW One Night Stand Arena | Get 7 points in Hall of Fame Mode |
| Great American Bash Arena | Get 10 points in Hall of Fame Mode |
| New Year's Revolution Arena | Get 9 points in Hall of Fame Mode |
| No Way Out Arena | Get 5 points in Hall of Fame Mode |
| Summerslam arena | Get 11 points in hall of fame mode. |
| Vengeance Arena | Get 6 points in Hall of Fame Mode |
| Wrestlemania 23 Arena | Get 12 points in Hall of Fame mode |