User Reviews (1 - 6 of 6)

Show these reviews first:

Highest Rated
Lowest Rated Newest
Oldest Most Helpful
Least Helpful

I like it.

4 Rating: 4, Useful: 50 / 50
Date: March 02, 2003
Author: Amazon User

I am an avid WWII enthusiast & researcher. I make WWII armor models. So naturally, anything with tanks and the likes I rather enjoy.

After playing all missions and maps, I have to say that this game is an impressive game. It is very stable and I really haven't had many problems with it. The programmers were of high quality, and knew what they were doing. The artists were also of high quality, and knew what they were doing. They made a great game in the end.

There are several drawbacks however:

The first one is the lack of a realism mod... I'm sure in time it will be developed, but the hit point based unit system is just too unrealistical to me (taking 5-6 shots in a King Tiger to kill an M3 Stuart makes me laugh, or making it so ALL tank killers can kill ANY tank, even IS3s and etc., or making it so Tanks can NOT hoze down infantry /w their MGs, but can run them over). I can totally understand the need for balance in any game, but lets face it, war is not fair, and any game emulating that should be able to emulate the unfairness.

The second drawback is the Earth-3 engine. All this engine is is an overlay to the DX components. Sure, with the Earth-3 engine, the water looks incredibly realistic, but with 15-30fps avg. with my G4 Ti4200 128DDR, it's a major drawback. After turning it off and using "Compatibility" mode, I am recieving the 50-60fps I should be getting.

The third drawback is the initial problem of the screen refresh rate problem. Initially, the program assumes your screen can handle a 120hz screen refresh... So naturally, when you try to run the game, nothing but a black screen will show up. Turns out you have to edit your registry and get it so the configuration utility allows you to select your screen refresh rate to something more realistic like 60hz or 75hz. Again, a major drawback to anybody w/o a bit of computer knowledge, especially since it's neccessary to fix or else you won't be able to play.

The only real other drawbacks are a few minor things... like not being able to assign units to a group "0", or having to use left-ctrl to assign units while right-ctrl does nothing, or having to manual go into the program settings and unchecking "lock camera" to be able to rotate your camera around.

All in all, there are a few minor drawbacks that can make anybody a bit skeptical of the game's ability, but you honestly need to realize that the only real major problem with the game is the HP based unrealistic system. For some people, thats fine, for the die-hard WWII enthusiasts like me, HP based system will really turn you off.

On the better note, the Graphics are amazing... Each model is superiorly done and they made sure that the scenery and the likes is just as well done. The maps that come with the campaigns are very very nicely done...ten times better than some games like Close Combat, Panzer General, or even Sudden Strike II. Trees are able to be knocked over, clearing paths through forests to allow your forces to flank the enemy. The explosions are heart felt, very impresive and well done.

All in all, I rate this game 4 stars, 1 star taken away for the non-existance of a realism mod, but I'm sure that will come to pass.

Great game, great replay-ability, great graphics, good interface, and excellent visual effects...

Great game to put in your WWII collection!

5 Rating: 5, Useful: 11 / 14
Date: March 22, 2004
Author: Amazon User

I got this game for free for my birthday along with Secret Service In Harm's Way. This game is RTS unlike Secret Service. This game was very good RTS game. I don't know about the accuracy because I don't know that much about tanks even though I'm interested in WWII. I think this game is just like Blitzkrieg but only with tanks. I didn't have any bugs so I was able to enjoy the game without frustration. It's very good WWII game and I enjoyed it a lot. It just like your typical RTS games and you will definitly be satisfied with your purchase. From the two birthday gift I like this game more though I shouldn't be comparing RTS to FPS. Secret Service was no match for World War II Panzer Claws even though I enjoyed Secret Service. That means this game is a damn good game because I enjoyed Secret Service but I enjoyed this game even more. The gameplay, sounds, and graphics are all amazing. I don't think accuracy matters as much as the execution of the gameplay. I really had fun playing this game and I think about playing again during classes. I can't concentrate in school because I think about how I should attack the enemies and stuff. If you really like games, you should know what I'm talking about. So I highly recommend this game to any RTS fans.
P.S. I also plan and think about Stacraft and Warcraft in school (it means I recommend them as well).

Try the demo before buying!

2 Rating: 2, Useful: 8 / 14
Date: June 14, 2003
Author: Amazon User

It is good that Eidos Interactive launched a demo so that everybody, who can download the 312 MB, can try it. The demo is regrettably limited to only 2 missions and no multiplayer function. It shows, however, that the game has very nice graphics, but overall it does not bring anything new or better than other Command and Conquer-style games. You are in command of a tank or a squadron, plus the support of soldiers and bombers. You control them with a mouse clicks and that's it (for me). I did not like it and also I think that the too limited demo version deters customers. I'm glad I saved few bucks.

World War II: Panzer Claws rules

5 Rating: 5, Useful: 5 / 13
Date: February 04, 2003
Author: Amazon User

I personally love this game. For a long time ive been a major fan of world war II and I games. And let me tell you. This by far to me is one of the hardest, and best world war II games out there. Not to mention then graphics are great. I also recommend to get world war III: Black gold, since it is made by the same developers. But this game is one of the best, and i absoultely recommend you to get it.

Definatly Worth the Money!

4 Rating: 4, Useful: 5 / 24
Date: January 11, 2003
Author: Amazon User

This is a great game! It is more than worth the mony! If you are planning on buying a game...BUY THIS!

IT BITES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

1 Rating: 1, Useful: 2 / 20
Date: June 27, 2004
Author: Amazon User

This game bites. Every time I play it freezes up and it's not even fun. It has horrible graphics so don't waste your money like I did. (...)

Review Page: 1 

Actions